it's good to have an end to journey towards, but it is the journey that matters, in the end ....

Sunday, April 24, 2005

thesis writing

a few good links :
http://bbcr.uwaterloo.ca/~brecht/thesis-hints.html
http://unicorn.sfsu.edu/~murphy/suggestions.htm

Some excerpts form the first link which in turn is adapted from "The Guaranteed Mackworth Thesis Formula", by Alan Mackworth, revised by Tim Brecht
Abstract
  • one page stating what the thesis is about
  • highlight the contributions of the thesis

Chapter 1: Introduction (~5-10 pages)

  • Thesis Statement (one or two sentences)
    • What is your thesis about and what have you done?
    • If you have a hypothesis what is it?
    • How will you test (prove/disprove) your hypothesis?
  • Motivation
    • Why is this problem you've worked on important
  • Goals / Objectives
    • What are you trying to do and why?
    • How will you or the reader know if or when you've met your objectives?
  • **** Contributions *****
    • What is new, different, better, significant?
    • Why is the world a better place because of what you've done?
    • What have you contributed to the field of research?
    • What is now known/possible/better because of your thesis?
  • Outline of the thesis (optional)

Chapter 2: Background / Related Work (~8-20 pages)

  • More than a literature review
  • Organize related work - impose structure
  • Be clear as to how previous work being described relates to your own.
  • The reader should not be left wondering why you've described something!!
  • Critique the existing work - Where is it strong where is it weak? What are the unreasonable/undesirable assumptions?
  • Identify opportunities for more research (i.e., your thesis) Are there unaddressed, or more important related topics?
  • After reading this chapter, one should understand the motivation for and importance of your thesis

Chapter 3: Theory / Solution / Program / Problem (~15-30 pages)

  • continuing from Chapter 2 explain the issues
  • outline your solution / extension / refutation

Chapter 4: Implementation / Formalism (~15-30 pages)

  • not every thesis has or needs an implementation

Chapter 5: Results and Evaluation (~15-30 pages)

  • adequacy, efficiency, productiveness, effectiveness (choose your criteria, state them clearly and justify them)
  • be careful that you are using a fair measure, and that you are actually measuring what you claim to be measuring
  • if comparing with previous techniques those techniques must be described in Chapter 2
  • be honest in evaluation
  • admit weaknesses

Chapter 6: Conclusions and Future Work (~5-10 pages)

  • State what you've done and what you've found
  • Summarize contributions (achievements and impact)
  • Outline open issues/directions for future work

Bibliography / References

  • Include references to:
    • credit others for their work
    • help to distinguish your work from others
    • provide pointers to further detailed readings
    • support your claims (if evidence can be found in others work)
  • Ensure that ALL bibliographic entries are complete including: authors, title, journal or conference, volume and number of journals, date of publication and page numbers. Be careful to at least be consistent in punctuation.
  • Learn how to use a good typesetting program that can track and format bibliographic references (e.g., groff, latex, frame).
  • Within the text of the thesis, a reference with a number of people can be referred to as Lastname et al. (where et al appears in italics and the al is followed by a period).
  • My personal view is that URL's are not valid bibliographic references. They and their contents change and they often contain material that has not been refereed.

Appendix

  • Include technical material that would disrupt the flow of the thesis.
  • Included for curious or disbelieving readers


0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home